Economics and Law Journal

76
-2023-
Primary Language
: tr
  • Emre Kaya
  • Özgür Saraç
Estimated Effects of the 2022 Minimum Tax Wedge Exclusion on the Tax Wedge in Turkey

ABSTRACT

While waiting for December inflation data for wage increase rates in Turkey in the last month of 2021, a part of the gross wage is included in the exemption with a regulation brought by the Government to the Income Tax and Stamp Tax laws, and an implicit increase is made to the wages in addition to the inflation figures. Although it mainly concerns the wages of the employees, this regulation also proportionally reduces the costs incurred by the employers as a result of the labor demand. Accordingly, although the exceptions include the gross wage, the gross wage is the employer’s cost. Some of the obligations that employers have to pay on behalf of workers, as required by law, are elements of gross wage. These costs, which employers have to undertake other than paying wages for each worker employment, are called tax wedges. According to OECD data published biennially, Turkey is two points above the group average with an average tax wedge rate of 38.8 percent for all wage levels in 2020. It is estimated that the tax exemption brought to the minimum wage will have a reducing effect on the tax wedge and this will be below the OECD average. In this study, Turkey’s tax wedge statistics for the period until 2020 are taken into account, (i) thanks to the minimum wage exemption introduced as of January 2022, the tax wedge rate will decrease, but the tax not paid due to the exemption will not result in favor of the employer since it directly reflects on net wages, (ii) It has been argued that legal deductions that are not included in the gross wage should be reduced in order to reduce both the tax wedge rate and the employer’s cost, and (iii) the minimum wage exemption will have effects on the minimum wage of the employees and will distort the justice in the income distribution.
Keywords : Tax Wedge, Minimum Wage Exemption, Increase in Employment

EXTENDED SUMMARY

Wages are an element of income according to the Income Tax Law No. 193. Basically, the income levied on the declaration can be assessed in different ways depending on the elements it contains. Wages are also generally levied by declaration and accordingly, the employer who employs a worker, in the capacity of tax officer, declares the gross wage of the worker to the tax office and pays the tax on behalf of that worker to the tax office. Theoretically, in this relationship, the worker is the taxpayer and the employer is the tax contractor. Income tax deducted from the gross wage of the wage earner is deducted at the source before it is received by the worker through withholding. On the other hand, for those who earn more than one wage income or other elements of income, income tax is calculated over the annual net amount of their declared income.

While the employer is responsible for taxes deducted from wages, the taxpayer is the employee who receives the income. Employees do not psychologically feel the pressure of the tax they pay, as the tax paid by deducting the employee’s gross wage is not received by the employee. In practice, a worker is not concerned with what his gross wage is, but with the money he will receive, that is, with his net wage, and supplies his workforce accordingly. However, this is not the case for employers. Since the taxes withheld by the withholding method are paid by the employer on behalf of the workers, employers come under the psychological pressure of the taxes they pay on behalf of their workers. For this reason, when dealing with who pays the tax on wages, wage tax (labour tax) is encountered, and when dealing with who pays this tax, employment tax (employment tax) is encountered. The psychological pressure caused by employment taxes is a factor that changes employers’ investment and employment decisions. On the other hand, this situation for employers increases labor costs, reveals important problems such as tax evasion, informal economy or under-the-counter production.

Income Tax paid on behalf of workers is just one of the costs that employers have to bear in return for labor demand. Apart from this, there are other direct costs among the costs that employers have to bear for each worker employment, and they are certain as they are determined by laws. Direct costs consist of (i) wages paid to the worker, (ii) income and stamp taxes, (iii) employee and employer social security deductions and (iv) unemployment insurance deductions. Those excluding the wages paid to the worker are called tax wedges. The tax wedge is defined as the legal obligations other than the net wage that the employer has to bear due to the employment of each worker. The tax wedge can also be expressed proportionally by dividing the sum of the tax paid for the worker and the social security deduction by the total cost of the worker to the employer. Indirect costs incurred by employers are not included in the tax wedge. For example, private vehicle or personnel service provided for the use of the worker, food service provided at the workplace, in-kind aids, workers’ clothing and equipment, severance pay expenses are not included in the definition of tax wedge.

Apart from the introduction and conclusion sections, this study is structured in three parts. In the first part, the tax wedge in Turkey will be compared with the OECD data and the situation will be determined by determining the prominent differences. In the second part, it will be discussed how the tax wedge is calculated over the minimum wage and a different wage level based on the data of 2020, and the effect of the wage increase on the tax wedge will be evaluated. In the third part, the differences that the minimum wage exemption made at the end of 2021 on the tax wedge will create as of 2022 will be examined over different wage levels, again the minimum wage, and it will be evaluated how the minimum wage exemption, which is a tax advantage, will affect the worker and the employer.

Türkiye’de 2022 Yılı Asgari Ücret İstisnasının Vergi Takozuna Tahmini Etkileri

ÖZ

Türkiye’de 2021’in son ayında ücret artış oranları için aralık ayı enflasyon verileri beklenirken Hükümet tarafından Gelir Vergisi ve Damga Vergisi kanunlarına getirilen bir düzenlemeyle brüt ücretin bir kısmı istisna kapsamına alınır ve ücretlere enflasyon rakamlarına ek ve örtülü olarak bir zam yapılır. Esas olarak çalışanların ücretlerini ilgilendirse de bu düzenleme, işverenlerin işgücü talebi neticesinde katlandıkları maliyetleri de oransal olarak azaltıcı niteliktedir. Buna göre, getirilen istisnalar brüt ücreti kapsasa da brüt ücret, işverenlerin maliyetidir. İşverenlerin işçilere yaptıkları ücret ödemeleriyle yasalar gereği işçiler adına ödemek zorunda oldukları bazı yükümlülükler, brüt ücretin unsurlarıdır. İşverenlerin her bir işçi istihdamı karşılığında ücret ödemesi dışında üstlenmek zorunda oldukları bu maliyetler, vergi takozu olarak adlandırılır. Türkiye, iki yılda bir yayınlanan OECD verilerine göre 2020 yılında tüm ücret seviyeleri için yüzde 38,8 ortalama vergi takozu oranıyla, grup ortalamasının iki puan üzerindedir. Asgari ücrete getirilen vergi istisnasının vergi takozunu azaltıcı etkisinin olacağı ve bunun OECD ortalamasının altında gerçekleşeceği tahmin edilmektedir. Bu çalışmada 2020 yılına kadar olan dönemde Türkiye’nin vergi takozu istatistikleri ele alınarak (i) 2022 yılının Ocak ayı itibariyle getirilen asgari ücret istisnası sayesinde vergi takozu oranın düşeceği, lakin istisna nedeniyle ödenmeyen vergi doğrudan net ücretlere yansıdığından işverenin lehine sonuç doğurmayacağı, (ii) hem vergi takozu oranının hem de işveren maliyetini azaltılması için brüt ücret içerisinde yer almayan yasal kesintilerde indirim yapılması gerektiği ve (iii) asgari ücret istisnasının çalışanların asgari ücretlileşmesi yolunda etkiler doğuracağı ve gelir dağılımında adaleti bozucu nitelikte olacağı savunulmuştur.
Anahtar Kelimeler : ÖZVergi Takozu, Asgari Ücret İstisnası, İstihdam Artışı, Vergi Takozu, Asgari Ücret İstisnası, İstihdam Artışı

Cite This Article

APA
KAYA, E., & SARAÇ, Ö., & . ( 2023). Estimated Effects of the 2022 Minimum Tax Wedge Exclusion on the Tax Wedge in Turkey. Çalışma ve Toplum, 1(76), 211-234. https://doi.org/10.54752/ct.1241228