Economics and Law Journal

Primary Language
: TR
  • Piraye Öykü Gökçe
  • Hatice Erol
Impact Assessment Of Actıve Employment Polıcıes: The Case Of Aydın Provınce

ABSTRACT

Nowadays, the importance of employment policies has increased in the area of struggling with socio-economic problems related to unemployment. The effectiveness of these policies needs to be investigated due to the fact that the target group of Active Labour Market Policy (AIPP), which have been used intensively in the struggle with unemployment especially since 2000s, is the disadvantaged groups,. The aim of this study is to assess the effectiveness of the vocational training courses within the scope of AIPP particularly in Aydın province.In the study, the projects ‘On- the-Job Training Programs’ (IEP), ‘Vocational Training Courses Without Employment Guarantee’ (İSMEK) and ‘Centers of Specialized Skills Acquisition’ (UMEM),carried out by İŞKUR, were focused.Semi-experimental technique was used in the assessment of the courses and programs A questionnaire study was applied to 400 people in total, consisting of people who attended and did not attend the courses between the years of 2014 and 2017. According to the research findings; although no significant relationship was able to be determined between participation in AIPP and employment, it was determined that there was a significant relationship for women when the findings were reviewed in a gender based way. Even though no significant relationship was able to be determined between participation in the AIPP and weekly working time in terms of registration to SSI, a significant relationship was found in terms of wage level. A significant relationship was not able to be found between the participation of young people between the ages 15 and 24 in the AIPP and their employment status. When the impact of course types on employment was assessed, it was found that IEP, compared to other course types, had a positive effect. The trainees criticized their inability to benefit from long-term insurance branches, their employment without any training in the jobs they entered through AIPPs and the fact that they were employed in different jobs instead of the job determined during the recruitment process. It was determined that those who had not attended the course were not aware of the AIPPs carried out by İŞKUR.
Keywords : Active Employment Policies, Impact Assessment, Unemployment, Turkish Employment Agency

EXTENDED SUMMARY

In recent years, as in the world, active employment policies instead of passive employment policies have gained an urgent character in the struggle against unemployment in Turkey. Active employment policies, which select disadvantaged groups that are relatively more vulnerable in the labor market as the target group, include a series of practices that are expected to serve both the fight against unemployment and the increase in employment by improving the quality and skill levels of individuals. Today, the need has arisen to determine the extent of the effects of active employment policies in combating unemployment and creating employment and to evaluate them in order to provide them with a more effective and efficient content. Impact assessment studies, which are generally carried out at local level, are important in terms of explaining the effects of active employment policies on the labor market and employment.

The main purpose of the study is to evaluate the effectiveness of vocational training courses on employment, which are included in active employment policies, in Aydın Province. In the study conducted for this purpose, semi-experimental technique from quantitative research designs was used to make effect assessment. The population of the study consists of the people who benefited from the AIPP from Aydın İŞKUR between 2014-2017 and the unemployed people registered in the same period. ‘On-the-Job Training Program’ (IEP), ‘Vocational Training Courses Without Employment Guarantee’ (İSMEK) and ‘Specialized Skills Acquisition Centers (UMEM) Project’ within the AIPP were discussed. . ‘Working for the Benefit of Society’ and ‘Entrepreneurship Courses’ were excluded from the research due to their differences in content and functioning with other programs, although they are included in the AIPP. Between 2014 and 2017, two groups consisting of 200 people who graduated from IEP, İSMEK and UMEM (experimental group) and 200 people who did not attend vocational training courses in the same year (control group) were formed. A questionnaire was preferred as a data collection tool in order to determine the variables of the studied group such as employment, wages and insurance and to reach the opinions on vocational training courses in the fastest way.

According to the research findings:

• It has been determined that AIPPs do not have an impact on employment in Aydın province and do not reach the entire target group.

• It has been determined that there is no significant relationship between participation in AIPP and employment.

• It has been determined that AIPP has more positive effects on women in employment participation compared to men, and a significant relationship has been found between participation in AIPP and women’s employment.

• When evaluated on the basis of gender, a significant relationship was found between the type of courses attended by women and employment. In terms of course types, it was determined in qualitative findings that the participants attending in MEK were predominantly women and that the purpose of participation was to socialize rather than employment.

• A significant relationship was not found between the participation of the young population between the ages of 15-24 in the AIPP and their employment.

• In the study, a significant relationship was found between employment channels and participation in AIPP. It is possible to characterize the fact that the graduates of the vocational training courses experience the role that İŞKUR has assumed in the market and start to use it actively as a positive step to overcome the current incomplete information problem of the market.

• In line with the needs of the labor market in Aydın Province, IEP was the most opened course type and it was determined that IEP had a more positive effect on job creation compared to other course types. In the short term, a significant relationship was found between participation in AIPP and employment, and it was found proportionally that IEP was more effective among course types than other course types. In the long term, participation in the AIPP has had a positive impact only on women. When education levels and skill levels improve, it can be said that women’s participation in the labor market increases and their employment is positively affected.

• Another issue that draws attention in the research is the relationship between the education levels of the people in the study group and their employment. From a statistical point of view, no significant relationship was found between all education levels and employment. The employment status of individuals with high school and equivalent education level and associate/undergraduate education level in the total of the whole working group was parallel. In numerical terms, it was seen that the employment of the people in the experimental group and who graduated from associate / undergraduate degrees was higher than the control group. It can be said that education level is a relatively sought-after criterion in employment in the labor market of Aydın Province.

• Trainees criticized their inability to benefit from long-term insurance branches, their employment without any training in the jobs they entered through AIPPs and the fact that they were employed in different jobs instead of the workplace determined during the recruitment process. It was determined that those who had not attended the course were not aware of the AIPPs carried out by İŞKUR.

In order to contribute to future studies, it should be noted that the AIPP can be included in the research in detail in which sectors and business sizes are used intensively and why employers prefer this program can be examined in detail. Cost-benefit analysis of the resources allocated to AIPP can be added to the impact assessment. Because one of the reasons for the emergence of active employment policies is the high costs of passive employment policies, while AIPPs offered to employers by the public can be abused by employers, and as stated by the participants in their statements in qualitative findings, they can be seen as an input used only to reduce labor costs without training. In order to prevent this, detailed outputs on both increasing audits and cost-benefit analysis can be obtained on possible reforms in programs and balancing public expenditures. At the point of reaching the target audience of AIPP, İŞKUR may carry out studies on the promotion of programs especially for the young population between the ages of 15-24.

Aktif İstihdam Politikalarının Etki Değerlendirmesi: Aydın İli Örneği

ÖZ

Günümüzde işsizliğe bağlı sosyo-ekonomik sorunlarla mücadele etmede istihdam politikalarının önemi artmaktadır. Özellikle 2000’li yıllardan itibaren işsizlikle mücadelede yoğun olarak kullanılan Aktif İşgücü Piyasası Politikaları’nın** (AİPP) hedef kitlesinin dezavantajlı gruplar olması nedeniyle, bu politikaların etkinliğinin araştırılması gerekmektedir. Bu çalışmanın amacı, AİPP kapsamında yer alan mesleki eğitim kurslarının Aydın ili özelinde etkinliğini değerlendirmektir. Araştırmada İŞKUR tarafından yürütülen ‘İşbaşı Eğitim Programları’ (İEP), ‘İstihdam Garantisiz Mesleki Eğitim Kursları’ (İSMEK) ve ‘Uzmanlaşmış Beceri Edindirme Merkezleri’ (UMEM) projelerine odaklanılmıştır. Bu kurs ve programların değerlendirilmesinde yarı deneysel teknik kullanılmıştır. 2014-2017 yılları arasında kurs/programlara katılan ve katılmayan kişilerden oluşan toplam 400 kişiyle anket gerçekleştirilmiştir. Araştırma bulgularına göre; AİPP’e katılım ile istihdam arasında anlamlı bir ilişki tespit edilmemekle birlikte, cinsiyet temelli değerlendirildiğinde kadınlar için anlamlı bir ilişkinin olduğu tespit edilmiştir. AİPP’e katılım ile haftalık çalışma süresi ve SGK’ya kayıtlılık açısından anlamlı bir ilişki tespit edilemese de ücret düzeyi açısından anlamlı bir ilişki tespit edilmiştir. 15-24 yaş arasında bulunan gençlerin AİPP’e katılımları ile istihdam edilmeleri arasında anlamlı bir ilişki tespit edilememiştir. Kurs türlerinin istihdam üzerindeki etkisi değerlendirildiğinde, İEP’in diğer kurs türlerine göre olumlu bir etkiye sahip olduğu tespit edilmiştir. Kursiyerler; uzun vadeli sigorta kollarından yararlanamamalarını, AİPP’ler vasıtası ile girdikleri işlerde herhangi bir eğitime tabii olmadan çalıştırılmalarını ve işe giriş sürecinde belirlenen iş yerine, farklı işlerde istihdam edilmelerini eleştirmiştir. Ayrıca kursa katılmamış kişilerin İŞKUR’un yürüttüğü AİPP’lerden haberdar olmadıkları da tespit edilmiştir.
Anahtar Kelimeler : ÖZAktif İstihdam Politikaları, Etki Değerlendirmesi, İşsizlik, Türkiye İş Kurumu

Cite This Article

APA
GÖKÇE, P., & EROL, H., & . ( 2022). Impact Assessment Of Actıve Employment Polıcıes: The Case Of Aydın Provınce. Çalışma ve Toplum, 5(75), 2795-2838. https://doi.org/10.54752/ct.1191462