Economics and Law Journal

Primary Language
: TR
  • Mehmet ÖÇAL
  • Özge KUTLU
The Dark Side of Employment: A Human View of Sweatshop and a Comparison With Sweat Index

ABSTRACT

Although working in jobs worthy of human dignity and in workplaces that comply with the standards set by social policy for these jobs are Decried as one of the most basic rights of every human being, it is observed that this right has turned into a commitment only in certain countries of the world. Countries that declare themselves as social states with their constitutions set limits on working life with social policies and punish it within the framework of corporatist understanding if capital crosses these limits. However, in regimes that have not adopted being a social state or have assigned themselves the task of being a social state, but have implemented weak social policies in terms of scope and intensity, the right to humanitarian work and workplace work remains only a goodwill wish. The work, which is carried out during long working hours, in unsafe /dangerous workplaces, with low wages, precarious, mostly informal, is usually carried out under the roof of sweatshops in the world. The study carried out at this point is based on the development of an index measuring the employment conditions of countries by clarifying the definition of the sweat workshop concept. Within the scope of the study, it was clarified how a workplace can be classified as a sweatshop, the dimension of the concept in employment was revealed, and the degree to which sweatshops provide profit to capital was shown with offers received from two different countries for the same product. The working conditions of the countries have been compared with the developed “Sweat Index” and it has been found that employment conditions in a significant part of the OECD countries face the risk of becoming a sweatshop.
Keywords : Sweatshop, Social Policy, Globalization, Decent work.

EXTENDED SUMMARY

Working in jobs worthy of human dignity and in workplaces that comply with the standards set by social policy are among the fundamental rights of every individual. However, the countries where this right becomes a real commitment are limited. Countries that declare themselves as social states determine the limits of working life through social policies and punish capital with a corporatist approach if these limits are exceeded. On the other hand, in regimes that have not adopted the concept of a social state or implemented weak social policies, the human right to work often remains a wish for good will. The social state approach aims to ensure the social and economic security of individuals. This understanding protects the rights of workers with policies regarding working life and determines the standards in workplaces. In countries where the social state is strong, workers are prevented from being exposed to long working hours and working in unsafe and dangerous workplaces. In addition, negative situations such as low wages, insecure and often unregistered work are minimized. However, in countries that have not adopted social state status or are weak in its implementation, such protections cannot be provided adequately and workers’ rights are frequently violated. The sweatshop concept generally describes workplaces where long working hours, unsafe and dangerous workplaces, low wages and insecure working are common. Such working conditions endanger the physical and psychological health of workers and create a work environment that is not worthy of human dignity. Sweatshops are common in developing countries and in regimes that implement poor social policies. Such workplaces provide unfair profits to capital by producing at low costs.

This study aims to develop an index that measures the employment conditions of countries by clarifying the sweatshop concept. The main purpose of the study is to determine with a statistical method which countries produce under sweatshop conditions and which ones observe humane conditions. Within the scope of the study, it has been clarified how a workplace can be classified as a sweatshop, the employment dimension of sweatshops has been revealed, and the extent to which sweatshops provide profit to capital has been shown with offers received from two different countries for the same product. The developed “Sweat Index” was designed to objectively evaluate and compare the working conditions of countries. This index analyzes working conditions and workers’ rights in workplaces through various criteria. The index includes criteria such as working hours, wage levels, job security, job security and unregistered work. These criteria are factors that directly affect the working conditions of workers.

Within the scope of the study, first of all, the concept of sweatshop was defined and the equivalent of this concept in today’s conditions was determined. In the second stage, the employment aspect of sweatshops was discussed in the perspective of the seriousness of these workplaces and the threat they pose to humanity. In the third stage, the working life statistics of selected countries were analyzed using the “feature scaling” method. As a result of these analyses, it has been revealed which countries have sweatshop-level working conditions. According to Sweat Index analyses, it has been determined that employment conditions in a significant part of OECD countries carry the risk of becoming a sweatshop. It has been determined that working in sweatshop conditions is common, especially in developing countries and regimes that implement weak social policies. This situation emerges as a serious problem that threatens the physical and psychological health of workers.

In line with the findings of the study, it is recommended to develop social policies at the international level to prevent the negative working conditions caused by sweatshops. These policies should include regulations that protect workers’ rights and guarantee humane working conditions. In addition, it is important to strengthen the understanding of the social state and disseminate this understanding in all countries. In order for workers to work with dignity, the scope of social policies should be expanded and their effectiveness in practice should be increased. It is the fundamental right of every individual to work in jobs worthy of human dignity, and protecting this right is one of the fundamental duties of the social state. However, in countries where working in sweatshop conditions is common, this right is often violated. The study clarified the concept of sweatshop and the dimension of this concept in employment and developed an index that evaluates the working conditions of countries. The Sweat Index is an important tool for developing social policies that protect workers’ rights and guarantee humane working conditions. The findings of this index provide an important basis for improving social policies and labor standards internationally.

İstihdamın Karanlık Yüzü: Ter Atölyelerine (Sweatshop) İnsani Bir Bakış ve Ter İndeksi ile Bir Kıyaslama

ÖZ

İnsan onuruna yakışır işlerde ve bu işlerin sosyal politika tarafından konulmuş standartlara uygun işyerlerinde çalışmak her insanın en temel hakları arasında gösterilmekle birlikte dünyanın sadece belirli ülkelerinde bu hakkın bir taahhüt haline dönüştüğü görülmektedir. Anayasaları ile kendilerini birer sosyal devlet olarak ilan eden ülkeler sosyal politikalar ile çalışma hayatına ilişkin sınırları belirlemekte ve sermayenin bu sınırları geçmesi halinde onu korporatist anlayışı çerçevesinde cezalandırmaktadır. Ancak sosyal devlet olmayı benimsememiş veya kendisine sosyal devlet olma ödevini vermekle birlikte kapsam ve yoğunluk anlamında zayıf sosyal politikalar uygulayan rejimlerde insani iş ve işyerinde çalışma hakkı sadece bir iyi niyet temennisi olarak kalmaya devam etmektedir. Uzun çalışma saatlerinde, güvensiz/tehlikeli işyerlerinde, düşük ücretlerle, güvencesiz çoğunlukla kayıt dışı şekilde gerçekleştirilen çalışma dünyada genellikle ter atölyeleri çatısı altında gerçekleştirilmektedir. Gerçekleştirilen çalışma tam bu noktada ter atölyesi konseptinin tanımını netleştirerek ülkelerin istihdam koşullarını ölçen bir indeks geliştirilmesi üzerine kurgulanmıştır. Çalışma kapsamında bir işyerinin ter atölyesi olarak nasıl sınıflandırılabileceği netleştirilmiş, konseptin istihdamdaki boyutu ortaya konmuş, aynı ürün için iki farklı ülkeden alınan teklifler ile ter atölyelerinin sermayeye ne derece kâr sağladığı gösterilmiştir. Geliştirilen “Ter İndeksi” ile ülkelerin çalışma koşulları mukayese edilmiş ve OECD ülkelerinin önemli bir kısmında istihdam koşullarının ter atölyesi olma riski ile karşı karşıya olduğu bulgulanmıştır.
Anahtar Kelimeler : ÖZTer atölyesi, Sosyal Politika, Küreselleşme, İnsana yakışır iş.

Cite This Article

APA
ÖÇAL, M., & KUTLU, Ö., & . ( 2024). The Dark Side of Employment: A Human View of Sweatshop and a Comparison With Sweat Index. Çalışma ve Toplum, 4(83), 1391-1424. https://doi.org/10.54752/ct.1569636